The Best Paella Pan – A Caliente Buyers Guide (July 2022)

This post contains affiliate links. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission.

The Best Paella Pan – Foreword

paella-giant-pan

Having the best paella pan to cook the glorious dish of saffron-infused rice with seafood, vegetables, or chicken is an absolute glory. Professional chefs and several home cooks worldwide have perfected this authentic dish by using some of the best paella pans available today.

I have also been lucky enough to have several of these pans in my kitchen. The pan’s rich history speaks for itself as it never disappoints in cooking up the best meals. Aside from paella, this pan has various other uses.

You can use it to sear steak, chicken, or fish and it also works well as a griddle for pancakes, eggs, crepes, and other food.

Having experience with owning and using a variety of these pans, I have chosen a few of the best paella cookware available on the Amazon market.

Before we Get Started : How is paella pronounced in Spain?

In many countries and regions that speak Spanish, the word for pan is paellera, while paella is solely the name of the dish. The correct pronunciation of paella in Spanish and also in Valencian is pah-ey-yah.” Source :https://www.pronounceitright.com 

The pans listed in my review have stood out by a large margin according to consumer reviews and satisfied home cooks.

Allow me to share with you a list of the best paella pans for your kitchen. The shallow pans are excellent for table settings and worth having around for everyday use.

How to Choose the Best Paella Pan – Buyers Guide

spanish flagThere are a few important things to note when choosing the best paella pan for you. Although every kitchen will function better with a paella pan on hand, everyone’s needs are different.

To get the best pan to suit your needs, you would have to take a few things into consideration.

Affordability, material, build, size, design, and heat sources are factors that will aid you in buying the best pan for your kitchen. Let’s have a look at these factors before you decide on your purchase.

Carbon Steel Materials

Traditionally, paella pans possess a carbon steel construction. It is a durable material that is designed to endure high cooking temperatures.

Aside from that, carbon steel is also known to have outstanding nonstick properties.

Over time and with careful care, it develops a natural non-stick surface that gets better with use.

However, it is important to note that to achieve this, the pan must be properly maintained and seasoned.

If the maintenance is up to par, then you will enjoy cooking in a high-performance paella pan. Many people opt for carbon steel pans because it is long-lasting when efficiently maintained.

Carbon Steel…Stainless Steel … What’s the difference ? > find out here <

In many countries and regions that speak Spanish, the word for pan is paellera, while paella is solely the name of the dish. The correct pronunciation of paella in Spanish and also in Valencian is pah-ey-yah.” Source :https://www.pronounceitright.com 

Garcima Mediterraneo Paella Pan Set with Burner

Garcima Mediterraneo Paella Pan Set with Burner, 16 Inch Carbon Steel Outdoor Pan and Legs...

If you’re looking for an all-in-one paella pan set, then the Garcima Mediterraneo Paella Pan Set with Burner is the ideal one. It is a 16 Inch Carbon Steel Outdoor Pan with reinforced Legs Imported from Spain and is large enough for up to 10 Servings.

The pan is made from durable materials that offer excellent heat distribution and retention. It is safe to use on stovetops, grills, and ovens and will stay in prim shape if well maintained. The burner fits 20-inch pans perfectly and also works great with smaller pans.

Each ring can be independently controlled as it has individual control knobs.

Pros
  • All-in-one paella kit including a burner
  • Made from durable carbon steel
  • It’s an efficient heat conductor
  • Suitable for indoor and outdoor use
  • It is sturdy and safe to use
  • Perfect for gifting
Cons
  • The steel pan needs proper maintenance
  • It is advisable to use a regulator to control heat settings
  • The burner tends to run hot even at lower heat settings

Cast Iron Materials

Cast-Iron-and-Carbon-SteelPots and Pans made with cast iron are durable and long-lasting. They are often passed down to generations are they are built to last a lifetime. When comparing cast iron materials to carbon steel, cast iron takes the win.

It offers better heat distribution throughout the cooking process and food stays warmer for longer.

However, when it comes to paella pans, cast iron materials are not always the best option. Some recipes call for increased or decreased heat quicker than others.

Paella pans made from cast iron materials take very long to heat up and it holds that heat even after the heat source is switched off.

This can ruin certain recipes and dry out your food by the time you’re ready to eat. Using cast iron pans to cook has its pros and cons and it’s vital to note that reducing cooking temperatures with them is difficult.

Victoria Cast Iron Paella Frying Pan Seasoned

Victoria Cast-Iron Skillet, Pre-Seasoned Cast-Iron Frying Pan with Long Handle, Made in...

If you’re in search of a pan that has long-lasting heat retention and excellent heat distribution, then the Victoria Cast Iron Paella Frying Pan is the one. It offers better performance when pertaining to heat and comes pre-seasoned for convenience.

The pan is seasoned with 100% non-GMO flaxseed oil and does not contain PTFE or any other harmful substances. It has a natural, easy-release seasoning that enhances with regular use.

Cast iron cookware is also a healthier option as it boosts the mineral content in your diet. The pan releases trace amounts of iron when cooking which is beneficial to health.

Pros
  • Excellent heat retention and distribution
  • The pan is pre-seasoned with 100% non-GMO flaxseed oil
  • Has comfortable double loop handles
  • Natural easy food release
  • The pan has many uses
Cons
  • To maintain the pans nonstick feature, re-seasoning is essential

Stainless Steel Materials

stainless-steelCooking paella requires quick temperature changes at certain points of the recipe. This will allow you a flawless paella dish that the whole family will enjoy.

Paella pans made from stainless steel are one of the best options for this venture. They easily adapt to temperature changes and are durable pans.

Additionally, stainless steel is also non-reactive which is excellent for cooking. You don’t have to worry about seasoning the pan and it is easy to clean and maintain.

Most stainless-steel paella pans are also compatible with all stovetops including induction.

However, make sure to read the specs and features when buying the best stainless steel paella pan for you.

Enameled Steel Materials

What are enameled steel pans? They are carbon steel pans that have a protective enamel coating for convenient cooking. Using a paella pan made of enameled steel materials will allow you excellent cooking performance just like their traditional counterparts.

The pans are also easy to clean because of their coating. However, it is also important to note that proper maintenance is vital to keep the pans in prim shape.

Seeing that enameled steel can chip or crack, using metal utensils with them is not advisable. Compared to carbon steel pans, enameled steel lacks some durability.

Non-Stick Coating

Non-stick coated pots and pans are used by millions of professional chefs and home cooks worldwide. They offer fuss-free cooking and are easy to clean and maintain. However, when it comes to paella pans, nonstick-coated pans may not be the best option.

The reason for this is that they are not as durable as other pans. The nonstick coating must be properly maintained to minimalize flawing. If you do choose a nonstick-coated paella pan, make sure that your choice embodies non-toxic materials.

Paella Pan Size

Paella recipes often cater to lots of people. The size of a paella pan is usually bigger than most for this reason. If you look at paella pans, you will notice that although they’re wide, they are also quite shallow. However, you can still use a large pan if you’re halving the recipe.

Choosing the perfect sized pan for you would depend on how many people you usually cook for. The paella pan has several uses and can be an everyday pan for your cooking needs.

You can cater to the family with no worries if you have this magnificent cookware in your kitchen.

Machika Polished Steel Paella Pan 18 inch (46 cm)

Machika Polished Steel Paella Pan 18 inch (46 cm)

The mouth-watering aroma of paella puts a smile on lots of faces in any home. The Machita Polished Steel Paella pan is 18 inches and perfect for cooking this traditional Spanish dish.

It is made from top-grade carbon steel materials and embodies an innovative design.

If you’re looking for fast and efficient heat distribution and conduction, then this is the ideal pan for you. The pan is durable, lightweight, thin, and convenient to use. It has a hammered dimpled bottom and cooks perfect paella every time.

Pros
  • Made from top-grade carbon steel
  •  Innovative dimpled bottom design
  • Serves up to 12 people
  • Has a two-year warranty
Cons
  • Needs proper drying to avoid rusting
  • Pan needs proper maintenance

Paella Pan Design

When it comes to paella pan designs, you would notice that they are quite similar. They are wide-bottomed pans with shallow sides that are perfect for this Spanish rice dish.

Their design also caters to a variety of other dishes that can be cooked in them.

You have a choice of the traditional paella pan design and those that have slight alterations with regards to handles. Some of the pans have handles on both sides while the traditional ones have straight wire loops that extend out.

The best from the lot is the pans with steeped handles as they are easy to transport. It also makes it convenient to fit on the grill or in the oven.

Heat Sources

heating

Paella pans are made from different materials that work well with most heat sources. It is important that the size of your pan works with the size of your heat source. If you’re using a very large pan, then a regular-sized stovetop will not be the best choice.

This is because it will hinder heat distribution during the cooking process.

Although some paella pans are constructed from materials that distribute and retain heat well, a small stovetop burner for a large paella pan is not the best choice. Other materials will allow ample heat in the center of the pan while the side stays cooler. This will cause uneven cooking.

My advice would be to either use multiple burners if you have a gas stove or else cook on an open fire or grill if the pan is too large for your induction stove or electric burner. Outdoor paella burners and grills are great heat sources.

However, if could opt for a round grill, you can cook your paella dish with coal or wood. It will add a smoky open-fire deliciousness to your paella dish.

Victoria Cast Iron Paella Frying Pan Seasoned

Garcima Mediterraneo Paella Pan Set with Burner, 16 Inch Carbon Steel Outdoor Pan and Legs...

If you’re in search of a pan that has long-lasting heat retention and excellent heat distribution, then the Victoria Cast Iron Paella Frying Pan is the one. It offers better performance when pertaining to heat and comes pre-seasoned for convenience.

The pan is seasoned with 100% non-GMO flaxseed oil and does not contain PTFE or any other harmful substances. It has a natural, easy-release seasoning that enhances with regular use.

Pros
  • Excellent heat retention and distribution
  • Pre-seasoned with 100% non-GMO flaxseed oil
  • Has comfortable double loop handles
  • Natural easy food release
  • The pan has many uses
Cons
  • To maintain the pans nonstick feature, re-seasoning is essential

Flat Bottomed Vs. Dimpled Bottom – Which is Better?

This is a question that is often asked when it comes to paella pans. So, which one is better?

Paella pans have dimpled bottoms for a reason. Dimpled bottoms maintain the shape of the paella pan and allow for even heat distribution and retention.

This feature also maintains the pan’s stature, so you won’t have to worry about it easily warping or bending. However, using it on an electric or induction stove is not advisable as the dimpled bottom pan will not have full contact with the heat source.

This is not favorable when trying to perfect a recipe.

Flat-bottomed pans also have their pros and cons. If your heat source is an induction or electric stovetop, then these are the ideal pans for you. It has full contact with the heat source and therefore heats evenly. Both pans work well with open fire or gas stove cooking.

Affordability and Price

Affordability and PriceExpensive does not always mean you’re getting the best paella pan. If budget is not a problem, then your options as to which pan best suit your needs is wide open.

I kept the big spenders in mind and carefully sieved the market to review the pans that stood out with consumer reviews, durability, and versatility.

However, if you’re on a budget, you will find the best low-priced paella pans in our review. We took a lot of things into consideration when choosing the best paella pans on the Amazon market.

Affordability and price were a priority therefore we have chosen paella pans to suit everyone’s needs.

Have a look at our budget pick and you would see why we chose it. It is a traditional pan that is affordably priced and has high durability. All in all, our best picks are worthy of all kitchens worldwide!

the Best Paella Pan FAQ (Freqently Asked Questions)

What is the purpose of a Paella Pan?

The purpose of a paella pan is to aid in cooking Spain’s unofficial national dish. Paella is a rice dish birthed in Valencia, Spain and the pan gets its wide shallow design to accommodate its preparation. Although it is called a paella dish, it also has various other uses. It can be used for everyday cooking and is ideal for searing and braising.

How do I use my Paella Pan?

You can use your paella pan to cook various versions of paella or other meals. The pan can be used on most heat sources depending on the materials it is constructed from. Using the pan to cook paella involves a lot of stirring as ingredients are added. You can serve your meals directly from the pan.

What methods can I use to season my carbon Steel Paella Pan?

Thoroughly wash and dry your carbon steel paella pan before seasoning. This will remove debris and any existing coating. Thereafter, add thin coats of oil and allow it to cook into the pan. This should be done a few times preferably on an open grill to get the best seasoning.

How should I clean my Paella Pan?

When cleaning a paella pan, using a thin bristle brush and water is ideal. First, remove any food that is stuck to the base. Using soap to wash your pan is not advisable as you will end up removing the caked in seasoning. After washing, make sure your pan is properly dried. This will avoid any deterioration and rust. Paella pans made of stainless steel or have enameled coatings can be washed with soap and water.

What is the meaning of a Pata Negra Paella Pan?

Pata Negra paella pans are restaurant-grade pans constructed with heavy-duty carbon steel materials. They are durable and versatile and can handle a heavier workload in the kitchen.

What is the meaning of Socarrat?

Paella is not paella without Socarrat! The crispy layer of rice caked in at the bottom of the paella pan is referred to as socarrat. It is the most flavorful part of the dish and lots of people enjoy it. However, having the right pan to achieve the crunchy layer is vital.

What pans should be an essential part of your kitchen?

It is essential for every cook, whether a beginner or an advanced one, to have a variety of pots and pans in the kitchen. Kitchens that have paella pans, stockpots, Dutch ovens, skillets, and saucepans are every cook’s dream. Having essential cookware pieces as a part of your kitchen will allow for convenient cooking every day.

Our Final Word and Recommendations

Cúrate: Authentic Spanish Food from an American Kitchen

Making delicious paella with the sought-after socarrat requires the best paella pan. Unfortunately, substituting the paella pot or pan for a normal one will not garner you the same results. The authentic traditional tastes and textures of paella require a dish that is wide-bottomed and shallow to be perfected.

Hence the creation of the paella dish by popular demand.

Amongst my best reviews, I have picked the best pans to suit the big spenders and those on a budget. Taking affordability, construction, materials, design, and other features into consideration aided me in choosing the best paella pans out there.

The products were carefully researched keeping all of you and your cooking needs in mind.

Seeing that I have narrowed down your choices and made things easier for you, take your pick of the paella pan that best suits your cooking needs.

Enjoy delicious paella and several other dishes while cooking with any of these fantastic cookware.

Lodge Carbon Steel Skillet, Pre-Seasoned, 15 – inch

Victoria Cast-Iron Skillet, Pre-Seasoned Cast-Iron Frying Pan with Long Handle, Made in...

For the best browning and searing, the Lodge Carbon Steel Skillet efficiently handles high heat. It is a pre-seasoned pan made of 12-gauge carbon steel materials and is the perfect pan to cook food evenly. The pan is very durable and tough and is built to last for decades of cooking. It is made in the USA and compatible with electric, gas, and induction stovetops. It can also be used on outdoor grills and for open-fire cooking.

The skillet is also easy to use and maintain. To ensure that your pan does not rust or damage, it is vital to thoroughly dry and season it after every use. This will ensure longevity. Seasoning the pan with vegetable oil will enhance the natural easy food release feature with every use.

Whether you want to use this fantastic pan to cook, braise, or sear, adding it to your cookware collection is a plus. It is a perfect addition to any kitchen as it is versatile, sturdy, and easy to use and maintain.

Pros
  • Heats quickly and evenly
  • Perfect for browning and searing
  • Has a tough 12-gauge carbon steel construction
  • Compatible with all stovetops including induction, outdoor grills, and open fire cooking
Cons
  • The pan’s surface is rough
  • Seasoning can flake if not properly maintained

Leave a Comment